Fox & SantiagoTechnology, applied.Call (877) 244-9687

Problem guide

Nobody knows who approved what

Nobody knows who approved what because most business software records that something was approved, not who said yes or whether that person had the authority. Jobber and Housecall Pro let the office mark a quote approved after a phone call, and Procore fills in a reviewer's name only on change orders a contractor issues downward. In FMI's 2026 study of contractors, client authorization was often a point of confusion. Name who can approve, and log the name and date with every yes.

A purchase order clipboard waiting on a parts counter

How it actually happens

An approval has two parts: the yes, and the authority behind it. The first comes easily. The second almost never gets written down.

It starts with whoever is standing there. A foreman finds a problem behind a wall. He asks the superintendent, the facility manager or the homeowner, and they say go ahead. The crew does the work that afternoon. Nobody on site asks whether that person can commit the owner's money, because the schedule will not wait for the answer.

The yes then travels to the office as a story. The foreman tells the project manager, who tells the estimator, who prices it. Someone opens the quote or change in the software and sets it to Approved. In Housecall Pro that reads Pro Approved. In Jobber it is a choice under the More button. Either way the record now says approved, and it says nothing about who agreed, when, or on what call.

Weeks later the bill arrives at the customer's accounts payable desk, and it gets compared with the contract, not with the story. If the contract says only a named officer can approve changes, the superintendent's yes was an acknowledgment that the work happened. A Floor Focus column from July 2025 told that exact story: extras approved in the field, refused at billing, and about a quarter of the money recovered.

The same gap opens inside your own company. A manager approves a purchase by text. The purchasing clerk sets the order to approved. Accounting receives the bill with an amount and no approver attached, because the approver's name stayed behind in the operating system. In ServiceTitan the PO request screen shows who approved it, yet the help center says there is no audit trail for later changes to the order. In Procore the person who pushes an item to accounting holds a separate privilege from the reviewer who approved the change.

Every business has its own version of the unrecorded yes. A sales manager okays a special price by text and the order ships at that price. A property owner agrees to a roof repair on a call with the property manager. A shift lead uses the manager's code to comp a table. Each is a real approval, and none leaves a record of who gave it.

Even a clean approval can be reopened. A subcontractor on Reddit's r/Contractor wrote in July 2025 that a lump-sum change approved in writing before the work came back, after completion, with a request for a full cost breakdown because the owner wanted one. The approval existed, but the backup that would have closed the question did not.

By month end, the approvals are spread across phones, inboxes, ticket books and status fields. No one can see them all, so no one notices the missing ones.

Acknowledged is not approved

Every dispute in this guide turns on one distinction. A signature that confirms work happened and a signature that commits money look identical on a ticket. FMI's 2026 study put it plainly: client authorization is often a point of confusion inside contractor organizations. Separate the two lines, name the people who can sign each, and the argument mostly goes away before it starts.

Signs you have this problem

  • A disputed charge comes down to whose memory of a phone call is better
  • The customer says the person who signed off had no authority over money
  • A quote reads Approved, and nobody can say whether the customer clicked it or someone in the office did
  • Two managers approve the same purchase because neither could see the other already had
  • Month-end review turns up bills, credits and discounts that no one remembers signing off

What usually causes it

  • A yes given on site, at the counter or by phone becomes an Approved status that someone in the office sets later, and the status does not say who agreedThe field-to-office split
  • Nobody asked, at the start of the work, who on the customer's side may approve money, so people take a yes from whoever is standing thereThe handoff gap
  • Approvals live in texts, inboxes, notebooks and dropdowns, so no one can see the whole list or spot a missing oneThe invisible queue
  • Verbal approvals are keyed into the system days later from memory, and the details that would settle a dispute are lost in the retellingThe re-entry trap

Find your cause

Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.

  1. Can the people doing the work name, today, who on the customer's side may approve money?If yes: the authority is known but may not be written. If no, start the authority sheet before the next extra.
  2. Do quotes, changes or credits get marked approved in the office after a phone call?If yes: the status hides who agreed. Add the who, when and how note to every manual approval.
  3. Have extras been refused because the person who signed had no authority?If yes: acknowledgment and approval are mixed on one line. Split them and match signers to the authority sheet.
  4. Does accounting see approved amounts with no approver attached?If yes: the name stays behind when the money moves. Check what your operating system actually exports, and keep the approval record where the bill is reviewed.

How it breaks in each industry

Electrical subcontractors on commercial work
Subcontracts often say changes need written approval with an authorized signature before work starts. The person on site who can say yes is rarely the person the contract names, so a signed ticket can still be refused. A 2011 EC&M article described one electrical contractor whose unpaid changes topped $140,000 for exactly that reason.
Residential HVAC, plumbing and electrical service
The homeowner says yes at the kitchen table or on the phone, and the office clicks Approved in Jobber or Housecall Pro. The status looks the same as a customer's own click unless someone writes down the call. A homeowner on Reddit's r/Contractor in 2024 said they had verbally okayed changes without realizing an additional bill for thousands would follow.
Property management
The management agreement sets a spending limit above which the owner must approve a repair. The owner's okay comes by phone or text to the property manager, the vendor is dispatched, and the owner statement later shows a charge with no record of who agreed to it.
Distribution and wholesale
A salesperson grants a special price, a freight allowance or a return credit over the phone, and a sales manager approves it by text. The order or credit memo carries the new number, and nothing on it shows who approved the exception or whether it was within their limit.

Where it breaks between systems

Housecall Pro estimates
A customer can approve in person, from the emailed or texted estimate, or the office can mark it approved after a verbal yes, which shows as Pro Approved. The office can also approve manually to override a customer's earlier decline. The status tells you the office clicked it, not who on the customer's side agreed.[8]
Jobber quotes
An office user can mark a quote Approved after the client says yes verbally, from the More menu. Signatures are not required to approve, and when the client does approve, the signature is saved as an internal note on the quote.[9]
Procore commitment change orders
Each commitment can have one Designated Reviewer, who must respond in Procore rather than from the notification email. Procore then fills in the Reviewer and Review Date fields. Procore's page says the field exists only on downstream change orders for a commitment, not on an upstream potential change order.[10]
Procore and QuickBooks Online
Job costs keyed directly in QuickBooks Online come into Procore as Direct Costs already marked Approved and not editable. Prime contract change orders and commitment change orders do not sync at all, so the approval in Procore and the money in QuickBooks never meet.[11]
Procore accounting approvers
Pushing items to the accounting system is a separate role. It needs Standard or Admin on the company's ERP Integrations tool plus the Can Push to Accounting privilege, so the project reviewer who approved the change and the person who sends it to the books are often two different people.[12]
ServiceTitan purchase order requests
Once a PO request is approved it moves to the Pending tab, a PO number is generated, and the screen shows who approved the request and when. That covers your own purchasing approval, not a customer's approval of extra scope.[13]
ServiceTitan purchase order history
ServiceTitan's help center says, as of July 2026, that an audit trail for purchase orders is not available, so a history of changes such as who created or received a PO cannot be pulled up the way it can for jobs.[14]
ServiceTitan and QuickBooks
ServiceTitan's QuickBooks Desktop and Online comparison lists no approver or approval-time field among what exports with a purchase order or bill. In QuickBooks Online the purchase order arrives as a single ServiceTitan PO Item holding the whole cost.[15]
simPRO purchase orders
Only employees with the relevant security group settings can approve purchase orders, and approval can be capped at a value, above which the order goes to someone with full approval permissions.[16]
simPRO invoice stages
Invoices in Simpro Premium can carry Pending and Approved stages. Pending invoices have no effect on the accounting package and approved ones are sent when data is exported, so the stage crosses over, not the person who set it.[17]
FieldEdge and accounting
A FieldEdge consultant's guide notes that finalizing a work order pushes it to the accounting software and tends to lock it, and recommends that only certain office employees finalize after a double check. Who finalized becomes the approval that matters for the books.[18]

By the numbers

FigureWhat it measures
87% vs 64%[1]How often specialty contractors with highly effective change order processes said they met or beat profit margin targets, against those with moderate or weak processes. Self-reported, from FMI's 2026 Project Management Study, Part 2 (243 executives and 84 project managers at general and specialty contractors). A correlation, not a measured effect.
41% and 28%[1]Share of executives, and of project managers, who picked ineffective change order management as one of their top three factors when profit goals were missed. Same FMI study.
92%[4]Contractors who say their change orders are not always paid in full. Clearstory, a change order software vendor, says the figure is based on a survey of nearly 200 contractors, general and specialty combined.
11%[5]Specialty contractors who primarily use software shared with the general contractor for change order communication, from Dodge research commissioned by Clearstory, as reported by Clearstory (June 2026). Everyone else is keeping their approvals in their own tools.
More than $140,000[2]Change work one electrical contractor went unpaid on because the general contractor's project manager signed it and the contract named only the president as an authorized signer. One reported job, EC&M, October 2011.
About 25 cents on the dollar[3]What one flooring contractor said he collected on extras a superintendent had approved, after the general contractor ruled that only the project manager could approve money. One practitioner's account, Floor Focus, July 2025.
7 to 8, up to 50[2]Change orders on a typical new construction project, and on a renovation in an older building, in the view of one electrical engineering consultant quoted by EC&M in 2011. An observation, not survey data, but it shows how many approvals one job can need.

Rules that apply

AIA A201-2017, section 7.2.1, the three signatures on a Change Order[6]
Under the unmodified general conditions a Change Order is signed by the Owner, the Contractor and the Architect. An approval from a superintendent or a project manager is not one of those signatures. AIA's standard Change Order form is G701-2017.
AIA A201-2017, section 7.1.2, who can order what[6]
A Change Order needs the agreement of Owner, Contractor and Architect, a Construction Change Directive needs the Owner and Architect, and a minor change can be ordered by the Architect alone. Knowing which instrument you hold tells you whose approval it carries.
AIA A201-2017, section 7.4, minor changes[6]
If the contractor believes a minor change ordered by the Architect affects the Contract Sum or Time, it must notify the Architect and not proceed. Going ahead without that notice gives up the adjustment.

Measure it in your own shop

From: Your quotes, change orders, credits and price exceptions marked approved in the last three months, the tickets or orders behind them, any authority letters, agreements or contract clauses naming signers, and the bills or invoices those approvals turned into.

  1. List every approval in the period: quotes, extras, change orders, credits, discounts and purchase orders over your internal limit.
  2. For each, write down who approved, the date, the channel (in person, phone, text, email, portal) and where the record lives. Leave a blank where you cannot find it.
  3. Mark each approver as authorized or not against the contract, the agreement or your authority sheet.
  4. Total the dollars on approvals with a blank name or an unauthorized approver.

Reading it: The share of blanks tells you how much of your approved work you could not defend in a dispute. The unauthorized share tells you whether the problem is your records or who your people take a yes from. The dollar total is what is at risk if a customer decides to argue.

What does not fix it

Requiring a signature on every ticket
A signature proves someone saw the work. If the signer could not approve money, the customer can treat it as an acknowledgment, which is how the Floor Focus contractor's superintendent approvals were treated.
Turning on approval statuses in the software
An Approved status records that a box was ticked. In Housecall Pro and Jobber the office can tick it after a phone call, so the status alone cannot show whether the customer agreed.
Saving every text thread
The text lives on one person's phone, is not attached to the job or the bill, and says nothing about whether the sender had the authority to approve.

What to try this week

  1. Build an authority sheet for every customer or jobBefore work starts, ask the customer, owner or general contractor to name in writing who can approve added work and who can approve money, with any dollar limit. File the sheet with the job or account and give the people doing the work a copy, so they know whose yes counts before anyone asks.
  2. Split acknowledged from approvedGive the ticket or sign-off two lines: one for the person confirming the work was done, one for the person approving the price. A superintendent or site contact can sign the first without having the power to sign the second.
  3. Write who, when and how into every manual approvalWhen someone in the office marks a quote, change or credit approved after a call or a text, add a note right away: the person who said yes, the date and time, and the channel. A bare Approved status cannot tell you later whether the customer or your own staff set it.
  4. Publish your internal approval limitsWrite down who inside the company can approve purchase orders, bills, discounts, refunds and price exceptions, and up to what amount. simPRO and ServiceTitan both support approval limits by permission or value, but only if someone sets them up.
  5. Audit ten recent approvalsPick ten recent purchases, extras, credits and price changes. For each one, find who approved it, when, and where the record lives, and time how long the search takes. The ones you cannot answer show where the trail breaks.

Where do-it-yourself stops

These steps start a record you can defend and show where the trail breaks. They still depend on people typing a note after every call, and the name stays in the operating system while the dollars move to accounting without it. The lasting fix is a tool built around your own authority rules, your tickets and orders, and your accounting system, so the approver's name and authority are captured at the moment of the yes and travel with the money. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.

How a Workflow Spec fixes it for good

Questions people ask

Is a superintendent's signature on a ticket enough to get paid?

Not always. It depends on who the contract says can approve changes. In a 2025 Floor Focus column, a contractor's superintendent-approved extras were rejected because only the project manager could approve money, and he recovered about 25 cents on the dollar. Get the authorized names in writing at the start of the job.

What should an approval record include?

Who approved, their role, the date and time, the channel they used, what exactly they approved, and the amount. If any of those would be argued about later, it belongs in the record.

Does Jobber or Housecall Pro record who approved a quote?

Both let the office mark a quote approved after a verbal yes. Housecall Pro shows it as Pro Approved, and Jobber saves a client signature as an internal note when the client approves it. Neither status by itself names the person on the customer's side who said yes on the phone.

Who signs a change order on an AIA contract?

Under section 7.2.1 of the unmodified A201-2017, the Owner, the Contractor and the Architect. A Construction Change Directive is signed by the Owner and Architect, and a minor change can come from the Architect alone, under section 7.1.2.

Should no work proceed without written approval?

FMI's 2026 Project Management Study found that the most reliable contractors follow one standard: no work proceeds without written authorization. In practice the schedule often wins, so the minimum is a written record of who said yes, captured that day.

Next step

How we fix this

This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.

Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.