Problem guide
Extra work never gets billed
Extra work goes unbilled when the people doing it start on a verbal go-ahead and write it down later, if at all. By the time a change order or scope change is drafted, the record is a text or a photo days old, and the customer can deny it as not documented in time. On AIA construction work, proceeding on an Architect's Supplemental Instruction acknowledges no change in price or time. Get a written yes before the work starts, and write the extra the same day.

How it actually happens
Extra work is almost never refused where the work happens. It is lost on the way to the office. The person in front of the customer says yes because stopping costs more than the extra, and the paperwork belongs to someone else.
On a commercial construction job, a foreman finds conduit that has to be rerouted around a duct that was not on the drawings. The superintendent says to keep going and sort it out later. The crew does the work that afternoon, because stopping the job costs more than the reroute. Nothing is written down, because the foreman's job is to keep the work moving.
The record of that afternoon reaches the office in pieces. A Reddit poster who described himself as running a mid-sized electrical subcontractor laid out the pattern in November 2025 (he later promoted a tool he built for it): the crew tells the general contractor "no problem," then sends the office a vague text or a blurry photo of a scribbled note two weeks later. By the time the change order is written, the general contractor denies it because it was not documented in time. The poster put that month's loss at about four thousand dollars.
The same thing happens at a smaller scale everywhere else. A service tech fixes a second problem the customer agreed to on the spot, and the office invoices the original call. An accountant on a fixed-fee return picks up a second state filing because the client asked nicely. A warehouse crew relabels a pallet for a client and nobody logs the charge. The hours are on the timesheet and the material is used, but neither reaches the invoice, because the ticket, the engagement or the order had no place for work nobody planned.
On AIA projects there is a quieter version. An Architect's Supplemental Instruction arrives and goes straight to the crew. The G710 form says the work is to be done without change in contract sum or time, and that proceeding acknowledges it. If the instruction carried real cost, it was given away the moment the crew picked up a tool.
Why the office does not see it
Cost records do see it, eventually. The labor and material land on cost codes or time entries that have no matching billing, and the supplier's invoice arrives for material nobody priced. By then the work is closed, the notice period has passed, and the conversation is about whose fault it was. The fix is not a better argument after the fact. It is a written yes before the work, and a one-line record the same day.
Signs you have this problem
- People mention extra work at the end of the day and it never shows up on an invoice
- Change orders or scope changes are written days or weeks after the work, from a text or a photo
- The customer denies the charge because it was not documented in time
- Cost reports show labor and material on codes nobody billed
- Supplier invoices arrive for material that is not in the original scope or any change order
What usually causes it
- The ticket, work order, time entry or daily report has no place for work outside the original scopeThe field-to-office split
- The extra is agreed verbally with the customer or their representative and never handed to whoever billsThe handoff gap
- Getting a written approval is slow, so people do the work and sort out the paper laterApproval drag
- Small add-ons are handled from memory as one-offs instead of through one routineThe exception swamp
Find your cause
Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.
- Does extra work ever start on a verbal OK?If yes: the approval is not on paper when it matters. Start with the written yes before work starts.
- Are change orders or scope changes written more than a few days after the work?If yes: the record is being rebuilt from memory, and late paper is the easiest thing to deny. Write the extra the same day.
- Do instructions that change the work reach the people doing it before anyone checks them for cost?If yes: you may be accepting changes at no charge by proceeding. Route every one through a pricing check.
- Do your cost reports show spend on codes outside the original scope with nothing billed?If yes: extras are happening and leaking. Measure them below.
How it breaks in each industry
- Electrical subcontractors
- The foreman hits work that is not on the prints, the general contractor's superintendent says keep going, and the crew does it. The record reaches the office as a vague text or a photo of a note, sometimes two weeks later, and by then the change order is denied as not documented in time.
- HVAC and plumbing service
- The tech finds a second problem and the customer agrees to the repair on the spot. The office bills the original ticket. The extra labor is on the timesheet and the part is gone from the truck, but neither is on the invoice.
- Accounting, law and other professional services firms
- On a fixed-fee or capped engagement, the client asks for one more filing, one more entity or one more review, and the staff member says yes to keep the client happy. The time goes to the engagement, nobody issues a scope change, and the hours show up later as a write-down.
- Logistics and third-party warehousing
- A client asks the floor to relabel a shipment, rework damaged cartons or hold inventory past its window. The work gets done, but unless someone logs it as an accessorial charge that day, the monthly invoice bills only the standard handling and storage.
Where it breaks between systems
- Procore and Sage 300 CRE
- Sage 300 CRE allows a contract line to be modified only once on a commitment change order, so when one change order carries several changes to the same line, Procore adds them up and sends a single value. Change-order codes must also be unique, or the export fails with a code-already-exists error.[2]
- Procore and Sage 300 CRE (export errors)
- Procore's troubleshooting guide lists export failures for a change order code that already exists on the contract and for a commitment that has been archived, so an approved change can stall between the two systems until someone fixes it by hand.[3]
- Procore and Trimble Spectrum
- Prime contract change orders can go from Procore to Spectrum but not back, unit-price change orders are not supported, and commitment invoices and payments do not sync, so a change approved in Procore still has to be billed and paid through the accounting system separately.[4]
- Procore T&M tickets and change events
- Adding a T&M ticket to a change event links the ticket and copies its line items. Creating the commitment or prime potential change order is a separate next step, and the ticket is not billed until someone takes it.[9]
- ServiceTitan (construction)
- Change orders are stored as estimates linked to the project, not as their own record type, and have to be approved and linked before they appear in a billing cycle. ServiceTitan's own guide warns that unbilled approved change orders are earned revenue that is not being invoiced.[10]
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures |
|---|---|
| 20%[8] | Average share of project revenue US specialty contractors said they lose to changes that go unbilled and unpaid; 12% of US firms said half or more. Self-reported, from the US third of a 537-contractor Dodge Data and Analytics survey sponsored by Procore (2022). The often quoted 30 to 32% is the four-country average, not a US figure. |
| 22%[8] | Specialty contractors in the same survey who still handle change orders mostly by manual methods. |
| 8.0%[6] | Underbillings as a share of equity for all construction companies in fiscal 2023 (CFMA 2024 Construction Financial Benchmarker, 1,290 companies). Underbillings are costs and earnings recognized ahead of billing; the ratio is a balance-sheet measure, not a count of unbilled extras. |
Rules that apply
- AIA G710-2017, Architect's Supplemental Instructions[5]
- The form tells the contractor to carry out the work without change in contract sum or contract time, and says proceeding with the work acknowledges there will be no change. If an ASI carries cost, the answer has to go back in writing before the crew acts on it.
- California Business and Professions Code 7159(d), home improvement change orders[11]
- On California home improvement work, the contract and any change to it must be in writing and signed by both parties before the work it covers starts, including the work under a change order. A verbal yes at the door is not enough there.
- AIA A201-2017, section 15.1.3.1 (claims notice)[12]
- Under the unmodified A201-2017 general conditions, a claim must be started within 21 days after the event, or after the claimant first recognizes the condition, whichever is later. Change orders (7.2.1) and construction change directives (7.3.1) are written instruments. Supplementary conditions often change these terms, so read your contract's version.
- FAR 52.243-4(b), (d) and (e), the federal Changes clause[13]
- On federal construction, an oral or informal order from the Contracting Officer counts as a change only if the contractor gives written notice of the date, circumstances and source and says it regards the order as a change. For those informal changes, no adjustment is made for costs incurred more than 20 days before that written notice. The right to an adjustment must be asserted within 30 days, unless extended. On a subcontract, these terms reach the sub only as the subcontract flows them down.
Measure it in your own shop
From: Field notes, texts, time entries and daily reports, the invoice lines and approved change orders, and the cost report for the same jobs, orders or engagements.
- Pick ten closed jobs, orders or engagements.
- List every extra mentioned anywhere in the work record, and tag each one billed, pending, denied, or never written.
- Price the denied and never-written ones at cost.
- Separately, list cost or task codes with actual cost and nothing billed that are not in the original scope.
Reading it: The never-written total is work your people did and the office never heard about. The denied total is work the office heard about too late. They need different fixes: the first is capture, the second is speed.
What does not fix it
- A change-order form in the truck or on the shared drive
- The person doing the work is rewarded for keeping the customer happy and never sees the denied change order. In the Reddit thread cited below, the advice was to require written approval, and the poster's problem was notes arriving two weeks late.
- New project software
- If the approval still lives in a text message that never becomes a change record before the billing cutoff, the software holds a tidy record of what was not billed.
- A weekly change-order meeting
- It reviews the extras somebody wrote down. It cannot catch the ones nobody wrote.
What to try this week
- No extra without a written yesBefore extra work starts, the person leading it gets a text or email from someone authorized to approve it, and attaches it to the job, order or matter. Write down who on each account counts as authorized.
- Write the extra the day it happensA one-line extra-work record the same day: what was done, why, hours, material, and a photo where it helps. A daily record beats a perfect change order written two weeks later.
- Price every instruction that changes the work before acting on itWhen a supplemental instruction, a field directive or a client request for more arrives, someone checks it for cost and time before the work starts, and answers in writing if there is any.
- Show the people doing the work what got deniedOnce a month, hand each lead the list of extras that were denied or never written, with the dollars. They rarely see the charge that died in the office.
- Scan costs for unbilled codesEach week, list the cost codes or task codes with actual cost and nothing billed that are not in the original scope. Each one is an extra somebody did.
Where do-it-yourself stops
These steps catch more extras, but the record still starts as a text on someone's phone and ends as a change order someone else has to reconstruct. The lasting fix is a tool built around your work records and your change process, so the extra is captured, approved and priced where it happens. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.
Questions people ask
Why do general contractors deny change orders?
Most often because the change was not documented in time. Subcontracts usually set a notice period for claiming extra work, and a change order written two weeks later from a text message misses it. Read your subcontract's notice clause and work to it.
What happens if we proceed on an ASI?
On the AIA G710 form, proceeding with the work acknowledges that there will be no change in contract sum or contract time. If the instruction carries cost, raise it in writing before the crew starts.
How much revenue do contractors lose to unbilled extras?
The best published figure is self-reported. In a 2022 Dodge Data and Analytics survey sponsored by Procore, US specialty contractors said they lose an average of 20 percent of project revenue to changes that go unbilled and unpaid, and 12 percent of US firms said half or more. The 32 percent quoted on Procore's marketing pages is the average across four countries. Your own ten-job check is the number to act on.
Is there a deadline for giving notice of a change on federal work?
Yes. Under FAR 52.243-4, an oral or informal change from the Contracting Officer needs written notice from the contractor, and no adjustment is made for costs incurred more than 20 days before that notice. The right to an adjustment must be asserted within 30 days unless the period is extended.
Should we get a signature for add-on work?
Yes: a signature or a written approval on the ticket, order or engagement for any work beyond the original request, with the price if it is known. It is the same rule as on construction work, at a smaller scale.
What are underbillings?
Costs and estimated earnings recognized on a job ahead of what has been billed. CFMA's benchmark put underbillings at 8.0 percent of equity for construction companies in fiscal 2023. Persistent underbillings on a job are a sign the billing is behind the work.
Next step
How we fix this
This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.
Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.
