Problem guide
Parts and supplies get ordered twice
A second order goes out when the person ordering cannot see the first one. Someone in the field calls a supplier, someone in the office orders from a vendor, and each order lives in a different inbox. In construction, a 2025 survey of about 50 SMACNA member firms found that more than half let someone besides a purchasing department order. Keep one open orders list by job or order, and check it before anyone buys.

How it actually happens
Here is a common version from field service. A compressor fails on a rooftop unit at nine in the morning. The tech calls the supply house from the roof and asks the counter to hold one. At eleven the service manager reads the ticket, sees "compressor needed", and orders the same compressor from the regular vendor for next-day delivery, because that vendor is cheaper. At two the buyer sees the vendor's confirmation in the shared inbox but has no way to see the call from the roof.
Both compressors arrive. The tech installs the one he picked up. The second sits in the stock room with a packing slip that names no job, until someone finds it weeks later and has to work out whether it can still go back.
The same thing happens anywhere more than one person can buy. A clinic's nurse and office manager both reorder gloves. A restaurant's kitchen manager and owner both add the same case to Thursday's delivery. A distributor's buyer and sales rep both cover one customer's order. The channel changes. The mechanism does not.
Nobody in those stories did anything careless. Each person ordered with the information in front of them. The problem is that the information was in three places: a phone call, a vendor portal and an inbox.
A new ServiceTitan user asked on Reddit in 2021 what tells the parts team a job needs a part, and where that job waits so it does not get lost in the hold column. The answer to both questions decides whether the second order happens, in any business.
Project work adds a translation step. Remarcable, which sells procurement software, quotes a senior purchasing agent at Morrow Meadows comparing the field-to-vendor handoff to playing telephone: without exact model numbers, the vendor assumes a different part. The same company describes foremen who cannot see what is already ordered or in transit and request material that may already be on the way. Read both as a vendor's description, not as measurement. They match what most project managers have seen.
Warranty and special-order items add a slower lane. One office worker on r/HVAC laid out the path: the defect is noted on the work order, someone in the office finds it, calls the factory for authorization, orders, receives the part, assigns it back to the job and schedules a tech. Every one of those handoffs is a point where someone else may decide not to wait.
Where the extra item ends up
A duplicate item is rarely thrown away. It goes on a shelf with no job or order, waits past the vendor's return window, and turns into stock nobody planned to carry. That is why duplicate orders and a messy stock room usually show up together, and why counting returns is the fastest way to see how often it happens.
Signs you have this problem
- Two boxes of the same item arrive for one job or order a day apart
- The person doing the work buys from a local supplier while the office orders the same item from a vendor
- Returns of unused items pile up in the stock room with no job or order attached
- Someone reorders an item that already arrived because nobody told them it came in
- A purchasing report shows a job's material at two or four times what was actually bought
What usually causes it
- The person doing the work, their manager and the buyer can all order, and nothing says who owns the order for a jobThe handoff gap
- Open orders live in email, texts and vendor portals, so nobody can see what is already comingThe invisible queue
- Receiving does not record against the job or order, so an item that arrived still looks missingThe field-to-office split
- A request waits on an approval, and the person who needs the item orders around itApproval drag
Find your cause
Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.
- Can more than one person place an order for the same job or customer order?If yes: nobody owns the order. Name one orderer per job before anything else.
- Do requests wait for someone's approval before they become orders?If yes: the wait is what sends people to buy around the system. Set a dollar line under which a request is ordered without approval.
- Do items arrive without anyone telling the person who ordered them?If yes: the duplicate starts at receiving. Mark arrivals on the open orders list.
- Do requests name the item by description instead of part or SKU number?If yes: the second order may be a correction. Require the exact item number on requests.
How it breaks in each industry
- HVAC service
- A failed part on a call gets ordered from the roof by the tech, and again from the office when someone reads the ticket. Warranty parts add a third path: the office calls the manufacturer for authorization and nothing stops the tech, who needs the unit running today, from buying the same part at the counter.
- Commercial electrical
- Foremen request material by description, and a request like two-inch pipe can mean EMT, PVC or rigid. When the first order arrives as the wrong thing, a second order goes out, and the first one has to be returned or absorbed as stock.
- Restaurants and hospitality
- A kitchen manager adds an item to the distributor order while the owner or a second shift lead places a separate order for the same delivery day. Each order sits in a different rep's text thread or ordering portal, so the walk-in fills with two cases where one was needed.
- Healthcare practices and clinics
- Supplies for the exam rooms are reordered by whoever notices the shelf running low. A nurse orders from the medical supplier's site while the office manager adds the same items to the weekly order, and nothing shows that the first order is already on the way.
- Distribution and wholesale
- A buyer replenishes an item from the reorder report while a sales rep places a special order with the same supplier to cover one customer. The rep's order is not on the buyer's open purchase list, so both ship.
Where it breaks between systems
- Viewpoint Field Management and Vista
- Purchase order requisitions created in the field portal are not saved to Vista until they are submitted and turned into purchase orders. Until then, the office looking at Vista cannot see that the field already asked for the part.[1]
- ServiceTitan and QuickBooks
- On QuickBooks Online a ServiceTitan purchase order arrives as one lump item carrying its whole cost, and ServiceTitan's own pages disagree on whether purchase orders reach QuickBooks Desktop at all. On QuickBooks Online, that means a buyer searching for an open order on one part will not find it by part number.[2]
- ServiceTitan and QuickBooks Online (inventory tracking)
- Turning on inventory tracking for an item makes ServiceTitan create a new item with an I- prefix and deactivate the old one. Unless the QuickBooks item name is updated to match, the next export creates a duplicate item. That is a duplicate record, not a duplicate order, but it splits the history a buyer would check.[3]
- ServiceTitan purchasing reports
- ServiceTitan warns that running the Purchasing Line Items report with Transaction Type set to All pulls purchase orders, bills, receipts and returns together and can double or quadruple totals. A report that looks like a double order may be a double count.[4]
- Procore and QuickBooks Online
- Commitments, which include purchase orders, are on Procore's list of records that do not sync with QuickBooks Online. A buyer working in QuickBooks cannot see a purchase order the project team placed in Procore.[6]
- FieldEdge and QuickBooks
- When a record that failed to post is retried or saved again while its first alert is still open, FieldEdge raises a Duplicate QuickBooks Request alert, and the original alert has to be cleared first.[7]
- Jobber
- In Jobber's own community, a user asked how to keep a purchase order open until goods arrive, and Jobber staff suggested a custom field for the PO number. Without a purchase order record, there is no open order list to check.[8]
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures |
|---|---|
| 45.5%[9] | Firms where an internal purchasing department places material orders, in the June 2025 New Horizons Foundation and Field Materials survey of about 50 SMACNA member firms. In the rest, project managers order (25.0%), project managers and field staff both order (22.7%), or field staff order alone (6.8%). Field Materials sells procurement software. |
| 41%[10] | Contractors that accelerated purchases after winning contracts to cope with supply problems, in the AGC and Sage 2025 Construction Hiring and Business Outlook survey of 1,109 firms. Ten percent stockpiled items before winning. Buying early means more orders open at once. |
| 45%[10] | Respondents to the same AGC survey reporting no supply-chain problems in 2024, up from 23% and 9% in the two prior surveys. |
| 39%[11] | Firms that accelerated purchases of key construction materials because of tariffs, in the AGC and NCCER 2025 Workforce Survey (released August 2025). A separate survey from the 41% above; do not add them. |
Measure it in your own shop
From: One month of purchase orders, supplier invoices, card charges and vendor returns, each with its job or order.
- List every material line by job and item number from all channels: purchase orders, supplier invoices and card charges.
- Flag any item that appears twice or more on the same job or order within 14 days.
- For each flag, check whether both units were used, one was returned, or one is still on a shelf.
- If you run ServiceTitan, run the Purchasing Line Items report once for purchase orders and once for bills, never with All, so a double count is not mistaken for a double order.
Reading it: The count of flagged pairs where one unit was returned or is still on the shelf is your true duplicate count. The channels on each pair show where the second order came from.
What does not fix it
- Taking ordering away from the people doing the work
- They order because a customer is waiting. Block them and they buy on a card at the nearest supplier, which is a channel the office sees even later.
- Returning the extra item and moving on
- Distributors charge for it. Ferguson's terms carry a restocking fee on returns unless agreed, and special orders go back only if the manufacturer accepts them and the buyer covers its fees.
- A weekly purchasing meeting
- Duplicates happen in the hours between a need and a fix. A meeting reviews them after both orders have shipped.
What to try this week
- Count last month's duplicatesGo through one month of orders and returns. Mark every item ordered twice for the same job or order, and note who placed each order and through which channel.
- Name one orderer per jobEach job, project or customer order gets one person who places its orders. Everyone else asks that person, including the people out doing the work.
- Keep one open orders listPut every open order on one shared list with the job, the part or item number, the vendor and the expected date. Nobody orders without checking it first.
- Mark arrivals on the same listWhoever receives an item marks it arrived on that list, with the shelf or location it went to. An item that came in should never look missing.
- Write item numbers, not descriptionsRequire the exact model, part or SKU number on every request, so the supplier and the office are ordering the same thing.
Where do-it-yourself stops
These steps cut duplicates by giving each job one orderer and one visible list. They still depend on everyone checking a list by hand, which slips on the busiest days. The lasting fix is a tool built around your jobs, your vendors and your purchasing system, so an order, its arrival and its job are visible to anyone about to order. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.
Questions people ask
Why do parts and supplies get ordered twice?
Because more than one person can order, and none of them can see what the others already ordered or what has already arrived.
What does a duplicate order cost?
The item, the return trip, and usually a restocking fee. Ferguson's terms say returns carry a restocking fee unless agreed and that orders cannot be cancelled without written consent and fees. No survey publishes an industry duplicate rate, so count your own.
Can we just send the extra item back?
Usually, within a window. Ferguson accepts stocked, non-special-order items within 30 days in new condition. Special orders are returnable only if the manufacturer takes them back, with its fees passed on.
Should only the office be allowed to order?
Not always. The fix is one owner per job and one visible list, plus a dollar line for urgent buys, not taking ordering away from the people standing in front of the problem.
Why does our report show a job's parts twice?
Check the report before the purchasing. In ServiceTitan, a purchasing report run with every transaction type pulls the order, the bill and the receipt for the same part, and an item costed on both the invoice and a bill is counted twice in project costing.
Next step
How we fix this
This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.
Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.
