Problem guide
Customer complaints get lost
Complaints get lost because they arrive after the work is closed, by whatever channel the customer picks, and most operating systems have no record for a complaint with an owner and a due date. A completed job is hard to reopen: until April 2026, ServiceTitan field users could not add notes or photos to a job once it was marked complete. Log every complaint as its own record, linked to the original job, order or visit, with one owner and a promised date.

How it actually happens
A complaint is the one piece of customer contact that shows up after everyone has moved on. The job is closed, the invoice is out, the person who did the work is on to the next thing. Most operating software is built around open work, so the complaint arrives looking for a home and usually finds a person instead.
Here is how it goes at a 25-tech HVAC and plumbing company. A homeowner had a new system installed Thursday. Saturday morning she texts the number she has, which is the office line, that the upstairs is still warm. The office is closed. On Monday the customer service rep sees the text in the inbox, calls back, and books a tech for Wednesday as a regular service call, because that is the fastest button. The install crew lead is never told. The text sits in the inbox, marked read.
Wednesday's tech finds a damper left closed, opens it, and closes his ticket. The homeowner is satisfied with the fix, less so with waiting five days, and leaves a three-star review that mentions the wait. The review goes to the marketing email. Nobody connects it to the install. The install crew does the same thing on the next job.
Nothing here was lost on purpose. The complaint touched four people, three channels and two jobs, and none of them held the whole story. The return visit was not booked as a recall, so it did not link to the install, so the callback never counted against the crew that caused it. In ServiceTitan, a recall can only be booked from a completed job, and even then the old job's required custom fields do not carry over. In Housecall Pro, the texting thread drops the tech once the job is completed, so even a customer who replies to the tech's last message reaches only the office.
The same path runs through other businesses. A tenant's complaint about a repair that did not hold reaches the leasing office while the work order is already closed. A diner's complaint reaches the manager on duty, then a review site, and the two are never matched. On commercial construction the complaint arrives as an email to a project manager who has already closed out the job, or as a Procore observation created without an assignee, which sends nobody a notice. Under an AIA A201, that email may be the owner's notice that starts the one-year correction obligation.
In a 2025 r/HVAC thread on install callbacks, one reply asked why the customer was calling the tech at all, saying it sounded like a problem for the office to handle. That is the right instinct. The office should own the complaint. It just needs a place to put it.
The count you probably do not have
Ask how many complaints came in last month. Most businesses can count recalls or refunds, if they were logged that way. Few can count complaints, because the ones resolved by a phone call and the ones that never got a callback were never written down. The measure below starts from what was written, and the gap between that and what your front-line staff remember is the size of the problem.
Signs you have this problem
- A customer calls back angry because nobody followed up on last week's complaint
- The person whose work it was never hears that it came back
- Complaints live in one person's texts, email and memory
- A return visit or redo is logged as new work with no link to the work that caused it
- Nobody can say how many complaints came in last month or how many are still open
What usually causes it
- There is no list of open complaints, so each one lives only with whoever took itThe invisible queue
- The complaint reaches the office, but not the person or team whose work it is aboutThe handoff gap
- Complaints arrive by phone, text, email and review site, and none of those channels is the system of recordThe exception swamp
- Whoever hears the complaint in person has no way to log it against work that is already closedThe field-to-office split
Find your cause
Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.
- Could you list every open complaint right now, with an owner?If yes: you have the list. If not, build it before anything else.
- Are return visits or redos logged as new work with no link to the original?If yes: you cannot count complaints by person or team. Log them as recalls or warranty items.
- Do complaints come in by text or email to whoever the customer knows?If yes: the channel is the problem. Route every complaint to the one list, whoever receives it.
- Do the people who did the work hear about complaints on it?If yes: good. If not, the same mistakes will keep coming back.
- Is warranty, callback or complaint work set to low priority in your system?If yes: the system is putting unhappy customers at the back of the line. Raise it.
How it breaks in each industry
- HVAC service and install
- HVAC School's Bryan Orr counts a return for a similar problem on the same equipment within 30 days as a callback, along with complaints from incomplete communication, diagnosis or repair. Manufacturer warranty programs add a clock: Lennox's Warranty Your Way terms give dealers 45 days from the failure diagnosis to file a claim.
- Commercial construction and roofing
- Under an unmodified AIA A201, the contractor corrects nonconforming work found within one year of substantial completion after the owner gives notice. The complaint is the notice. If it lands in a project manager's inbox after the project is closed out, the correction period runs while nobody owns it.
- Plumbing and electrical service
- Most complaints are about a return visit not happening or a fix that did not hold. When the return is booked as a new call, the tech who did the first visit may never learn of it, and the company never sees which repairs come back.
- Property management
- A tenant complains to the leasing office, the maintenance tech, the portal and the owner's email, sometimes all four. The work order for the fix gets closed when the vendor leaves, while the complaint itself, that the fix did not hold or took too long, stays in whichever inbox it landed in.
- Restaurants and hospitality
- A guest complains to the server, the manager on duty or a review site days later. The comp is rung on the register, the manager's note goes in a shift log, and the review lands with whoever watches the review account, so nobody sees that the same dish or the same shift keeps coming up.
Where it breaks between systems
- ServiceTitan completed jobs
- ServiceTitan's April 2026 release note says that before the change, field users had no way to add notes, photos or forms to a job once it was marked complete. Its own example: a homeowner raises a follow-up concern the same day, and the tech opens the completed job and cannot record it.[1]
- ServiceTitan recall jobs
- Only completed jobs can be recalled, recalls are set to No Charge automatically, and when a recall is booked from the old job's page, required custom fields and pre-filled job summaries do not carry over.[2]
- ServiceTitan job type priorities
- ServiceTitan's example table of common job types lists Warranty at Low priority, Call Back at Normal and Emergency Call at Urgent. Shops set these themselves, and the example is where many start.[3]
- ServiceTitan Follow Up screen
- The Follow Up screen tracks unsold and sold estimates, surveys, recurring service events and expiring memberships. It has no tab for complaints.[4]
- ServiceTitan accounting notes
- A note added in the Accounting section appears only in Accounting, not on the customer, location, job or project record. A billing complaint logged there is invisible to the CSR and the tech.[5]
- Housecall Pro customer chat
- Techs are added to a customer's chat only while assigned to that customer's job and removed when the job is completed, deleted or canceled. Office staff are added by default. A complaint texted the day after goes to the office, not to the person who did the work.[6]
- Jobber app notes offline
- A note or attachment saved without signal stays on the phone until the app is open and online, and nobody else sees it until then. If the tech logs out, force-closes, deletes or updates the app first, the note is lost.[7]
- Procore Observations
- Observation notifications are not sent automatically when an observation is created; someone clicks Send Item. An observation created without an assignee sends no notification at all, though adding an assignee later does send one.[8]
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures |
|---|---|
| 81,925 reports[11] | Consumer reports filed with the FTC in 2024 under Home Improvement, Repair and Solar, 1.27% of all reports and 16th of 29 categories (FTC Consumer Sentinel Data Book, March 2025). These are unverified consumer reports, and the category includes solar, appliances and home warranties. |
| $650 and $850[12] | ACCA's worked example of what one callback costs a contractor: about $650 for a service callback and $850 for an install callback, about $80,000 a year at a 5% callback rate for a $2 million shop. It is example arithmetic on an association blog, not a survey. |
| 53%[13] | Consumers who expect a business to respond to a negative online review within a week; one in three expect three days or less (ReviewTrackers 2022 consumer survey, vendor, all industries). |
| 2 to 3 weeks, about 120 days[14] | California's Contractors State License Board sends contact letters to both parties within 2 to 3 weeks of a complaint, and its arbitration takes about 120 days to resolve a dispute. |
Rules that apply
- Oregon ORS 701.143(2), complaint deadline[16]
- For work on an existing structure, the Construction Contractors Board must receive an owner's complaint no later than one year after the work was substantially completed. New structures have their own clock.
- California CSLB jurisdiction[15]
- The CSLB can act on a complaint up to four years from the violation, and up to ten years for some hidden structural defects. Complaints involving health and safety get top priority.
- Maryland Board of HVACR Contractors, response to a complaint[17]
- The board asks the contractor for a written response within 30 days. Failing to respond can bring a reprimand, suspension or revocation, or a civil penalty of up to $5,000. The board cannot order a contractor back to the job.
- AIA A201-2017, Section 12.2.2.1, one-year correction period[18]
- Where the A201 is the contract, the contractor corrects nonconforming work found within a year of substantial completion promptly after the owner's notice, and an owner who fails to give notice can waive the right. AIA says to call it a correction period, not a warranty.
Measure it in your own shop
From: Recall, warranty, redo and no-charge records in your operating system for the last six months, the original work they link to (or should link to), credits and refunds in accounting, and your review sites.
- List every no-charge, recall, warranty or redo record and every credit or refund issued for a service problem.
- Match each one to the original work. Count how many have no link.
- For each, find the date of the first complaint (call log, text, email or review) and the date it was resolved with the customer.
- Count how many complaints the person who did the original work was told about.
Reading it: Your callback rate is recalls divided by completed work. The median days from first complaint to resolution is your response time, and the share with no link to the original work is the share you cannot learn from.
What does not fix it
- A complaints inbox
- It collects email. Complaints also arrive by phone, text, in person and by review, and an inbox has no owner field or due date.
- A weekly service meeting
- It reviews complaints somebody remembered to bring. The ones that never got written down are not on the agenda.
- Telling staff to note complaints on the job
- If the job is already closed, the person may have no way to add the note, which ServiceTitan's own release notes describe as the situation until April 2026. If the note stays on a phone without signal, Jobber warns it can be lost.
- Checklists to cut callbacks
- ACCA's own example notes that checklists filled out on autopilot after the job do not make a meaningful dent in callbacks. Fewer callbacks helps, but the ones that happen still need an owner.
What to try this week
- Create one complaint recordA complaint gets its own entry: date, customer, original job, order or visit, what they said in their words, who owns it, the date you promised to respond, and how it closed. A spreadsheet works to start, as long as it is the only place.
- Link it to the work that caused itBook any return visit or redo as a recall or warranty item tied to the original, not as fresh work. Without the link nobody can count complaints by person, team, product or location.
- Tell the person whose work it wasEvery complaint about work that was done goes to the person or team lead who did it, the same week. One HVAC trainer wrote in a comment on HVAC School that his company had callbacks but no system to tell the installer what happened, where or when.
- Give complaints a priority above routineIf your system sets callbacks, warranty work or complaint tickets to low priority, change it. An unhappy existing customer is not a low-priority request.
- Close it with the customer, not the ticketA complaint is closed when the customer has been told what was done and agreed, not when the return visit or the ticket is marked complete. Record that conversation and its date.
Where do-it-yourself stops
These steps give complaints an owner and a date, but someone still has to notice that a text, a voicemail or a review is a complaint, type it into the list, find the original work and chase the follow-up by hand. The lasting fix is a tool built around the system that runs your work and your phones, so a complaint from any channel lands as a record tied to the original work, with an owner and a due date that nobody can lose. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.
Questions people ask
What counts as a callback?
HVAC School's Bryan Orr defines it as a return for a similar issue on the same equipment within 30 days, work you cannot charge because it ties to prior work, or a complaint from incomplete communication, diagnosis or repair. Pick a definition and use it every month.
What is a normal callback rate?
There is no published industry rate we could verify. ACCA's blog uses 5% in a worked example and calls it more common than we would like to admit. Measure your own: recalls divided by completed jobs.
Do we have to keep a complaint log?
No federal rule requires one. But licensing boards act on complaints with deadlines of their own: Maryland's HVACR board asks for a written response within 30 days, and California's board can act up to four years after a violation.
How fast should we respond to a complaint?
For online reviews, ReviewTrackers' 2022 survey found 53% of consumers expect a response to a negative review within a week. For a complaint by phone, acknowledge the same day and give a date for the fix.
Can the tech who did the job see a complaint texted after the visit?
In Housecall Pro, not by default. Techs are removed from the customer chat when the job is completed; office staff stay on it. Someone in the office has to pass it on.
Next step
How we fix this
This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.
Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.
