Problem guide
Rework isn't recorded
Rework goes unrecorded because fixing the mistake is faster than writing it up, and no field in the job cost, the order or the accounting system is waiting for it. By the definition Navigant used, rework is work done twice with no change order behind it, so nothing bills it and nothing flags it. In construction, one 2025 study found a single contractor's precompletion rework underreported by 300%. Log each redo against the original job or order with a reason.

How it actually happens
Rework starts the moment someone notices the work is wrong. What happens next depends on who noticed and how busy they are. A person who catches their own mistake usually fixes it on the spot. A lead who catches someone else's sends it back with a word. An inspector or reviewer who fails it writes it up, because that is their job, and the work gets done again.
Here is an example of the common path in a shop. A batch of brackets comes off the press brake with one flange a few degrees off. The operator resets and reforms most of the batch before lunch. His hours go against the job as normal run time. Nothing in the time system knows the second pass happened. Two months later the same customer reorders. The estimator quotes from the first job's hours, which look normal, and the job loses money in the same place again.
The same path runs through a warehouse and an office. A picker ships the wrong item, and the replacement goes out the next day on the general freight account. A staff accountant's work comes back from review twice, and the hours are written down on the engagement without a note. Each order or file looks like it was done once.
The record breaks at three handoffs. The first is between the person and paper: writing it up takes longer than fixing it, and nothing good happens to the person who reports it. The second is between the work and the job cost: even when a lead knows about a redo, the time entry has no rework code, so the hours land on normal time, overhead or the next job. The third is between the people doing the work and the people quoting it: the lead knows the bracket always needs a second hit, but that knowledge never reaches the quote.
Software rarely helps on its own. A change log has categories for customer changes and allowances, and a redo is neither. An inspection system can show a weld still open without showing how many repair loops it took. A cutting station in manual mode can leave the stock count untouched when a spool is recut. Each system records what it was built to record, and a redo usually falls between them.
The research, which comes from construction, is consistent on one point even where the numbers disagree. Navigant's definition makes rework the work with no change order behind it, which means nothing downstream bills it. A 2018 study of one contractor found a tiny share of events carrying a third of the cost, so the redos costing you the most are the ones worth catching. And a 2025 study of one contractor found the recorded figure was a fraction of the real one.
The quality record is not the cost record
Certified steel shops already write down nonconforming work, because AISC 207 requires it. That record says which pieces, what was wrong, how it was treated and who signed off. It does not say how many hours the fix took. Adding two fields to the nonconformance entry, hours and material, is the quickest way for a certified shop to turn a record it already keeps into the rework cost it is missing. Any business with a review step, a returns log or a complaint record can do the same.
Signs you have this problem
- Work runs over its hours and nobody can say where the extra time went
- The same product, file or customer keeps needing a second pass, but it only comes up in conversation
- People fix problems quietly so the work does not look bad
- Rework time lands on the next job or on general overhead instead of the work that caused it
- An item fails inspection or review several times and the record shows one failure
- Quotes for repeat work ignore the rework it always needs
What usually causes it
- Writing up a redo takes longer than doing it, and there is no short form where the work happens, so people skip itThe exception swamp
- Rework hours and scrap are booked as normal time or overhead, so the job cost never shows themThe invisible queue
- What went wrong is known by the people doing the work but never reaches whoever quotes or plans the next one, so it repeatsThe handoff gap
Find your cause
Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.
- Do people fix mistakes without telling anyone?If yes: recording costs more than fixing. Put a four-column tally where the work happens and make it about causes.
- Do rework hours go on overhead or the next job?If yes: the time is recorded but in the wrong place. Add a rework cost code and charge it to the original work.
- Does your inspection, review or nonconformance record exist but never reach the job cost?If yes: you have a quality record and no cost record. Add hours and material to each entry.
- Does whoever quotes repeat work start from the original hours?If yes: what the people doing the work know stops with them. Bring the estimator or account owner to the weekly rework review.
How it breaks in each industry
- Structural steel fabrication
- An AISC-certified shop must mark nonconforming work and record the pieces, the problem, the treatment, who authorized it and the reinspection. That is a quality record, not a cost record. The hours to fix the piece still go wherever the welder's time card says.
- Mechanical and pipe spool prefab
- A spool cut wrong gets recut from stock. In STRATUS's manual cutting mode the remaining stock length does not change when the cut is marked done, so the recut leaves no trace in material or scrap. The second cut looks like the first.
- Distribution and wholesale
- A mis-pick ships, the customer calls, and the warehouse picks, packs and ships the right item again. The second shipment and the return freight land on general shipping cost, and the order looks like it shipped once.
- Accounting and professional services firms
- A return or a deliverable goes back for a second pass after review or after the client spots an error. The extra hours get written down or absorbed into the engagement, and nothing records why, so next year's budget is set from the same hours.
Where it breaks between systems
- Procore change events
- Procore's default change reasons are Allowance, Backcharge, Client Request, Design Development and Existing Condition. Companies can hide these and add their own. Reading that list, self-performed rework that is not a backcharge has no default reason, so it needs a custom reason or a rework cost code.[10]
- Tekla PowerFab inspections
- A failed inspection stays flagged until a follow-up test passes. In the inspection status, follow-up tests count as one no matter how many times they were run, so three repair loops on one weld look like one. The page says nothing about repair hours or cost.[11]
- Acumatica Manufacturing scrap actions
- Each operation has a scrap action. Under No Action, scrap costs are not posted to a specific general ledger account. Rework appears only as one possible fate of a scrapped item, alongside selling it at a discount, using it as material or discarding it. Write-Off and Quarantine post scrap to a separate account through a reason code.[12]
- GTP STRATUS Workstation (cutting)
- When cutting in manual mode, the Remaining stock length does not change when the operator presses Done. GTP says managing the material and the scrap is left to the person cutting.[13]
- ServiceTitan and QuickBooks Online
- With service location mapping on, invoices and credit memos export to a QuickBooks Online sub-customer for each service location. The fields the page describes are customer, location and amounts; nothing on it carries a rework reason or a link back to the original job.[14]
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures |
|---|---|
| 300%[3] | How far one contractor's precompletion rework costs were underreported, measured at an average of 0.38% of contract value (range 0.01% to 3.67%). Peter Love, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, published online October 2025. One contractor. |
| 88 of 19,605[2] | Rework events that carried 34% of total rework cost at one Australian contractor across 346 projects from 2009 to 2015. Mean rework cost was 0.39% of contract value on the 98 projects with complete cost data, and mean yearly profit was reduced by 28%. Love and others, Production Planning and Control, 2018. |
| 4.03%[1] | Median direct cost of rework on average projects, from older studies compiled by the Navigant Construction Forum in 2012. Navigant calls it the lower end of the range and suggests marking direct rework up by 80% for indirect costs such as supervision and project management. |
| About one third[1] | Share of respondents in a 2001 Construction Industry Institute survey who believed their recorded rework was only 50 to 75 percent of actual rework. A belief, not a measurement, cited secondhand in the 2012 Navigant paper. |
| 3.9 hours a week[5] | Time respondents said they spent dealing with mistakes and rework, including assessing the cost and determining why, in a 2018 FMI survey for PlanGrid, a software vendor. 599 respondents, 500 in the US. Self-reported. |
| 19% and 30%[6] | Owners' estimate of rework as a share of total project cost, and the share general and specialty contractors said is recoverable, in a 2022 FMI survey sponsored by Procore. 979 respondents worldwide, 25% in the US. An estimate from a survey, far above every measured study on this page. |
Rules that apply
- AISC 207-20 (2020 edition, since superseded), section 1.15.2, nonconforming work[7]
- AISC-certified shops must mark nonconforming work as soon as practical and keep records of the pieces affected, the nature of the nonconformance, the treatment chosen, who authorized it and reinspection results. The glossary defines rework as action that makes nonconforming work conform. The standard does not require hours or dollars. It binds AISC-certified shops alone, and 207-20 was the edition read; confirm it is still current.
- AISC 207-20 (2020 edition, since superseded), sections 1.16 and 1.5.3(d), corrective action and management review[7]
- Corrective action is required when periodic review of nonconformance reports shows a repeating problem, and executive management must assess the number and severity of nonconformances at least once a year. A shop cannot trend a redo nobody wrote down.
- FAR 52.246-12, Inspection of Construction[8]
- Where the clause is in a federal construction contract, the contractor keeps an adequate inspection system and complete inspection records available to the Government, and replaces or corrects nonconforming work without charge. FAR 46.312 requires it in fixed-price construction contracts above the simplified acquisition threshold. It does not require a rework cost code.
- 29 CFR 1904.4(a), OSHA recording criteria (does not apply)[9]
- OSHA recordkeeping covers work-related fatalities, injuries and illnesses only. It is not a rework rule, and citing it for rework records is a mistake.
Measure it in your own shop
From: Time cards or time entries by job, nonconformance, inspection or review reports, scrap tickets, returns and reshipments, and the job cost reports for the same work.
- List every nonconformance, failed inspection or review, and customer return from the last three months.
- For each one, look for rework hours or material on the original job's or order's cost report.
- Count how many have a cost entry and how many do not.
- For the ones without, ask the lead how long the fix took and write down the estimate.
Reading it: The share of quality events with no cost entry is your recording gap. The estimated hours on those events are the rework your job costs are missing. If repeat work keeps showing the same reason, that is the first thing to take to whoever quotes it.
What does not fix it
- Telling people to write it down
- Without a short form where the work happens and a cost code to put it on, the instruction lasts a week. The effort to record has to be smaller than the effort to fix.
- Treating the quality record as the rework record
- Nonconformance and inspection records say what was wrong and how it was treated. They do not say how many hours it took, and follow-up tests can count as one however many loops it took.
- Using an industry rework percentage to price work
- Measured construction studies range from about 0.4% at one contractor to a 4.03% median in older compilations, and survey estimates go far higher. None of them is your business. Only your own tally is.
What to try this week
- Put a rework tally where the work happensFor two weeks, keep one sheet per station, team or desk with four columns: original job or order number, what was done again, rough hours, and a reason. Say plainly that it is for finding causes, not for blame.
- Limit the reasons to sixFor example: wrong or old instructions, handling damage, setup or entry error, bad material or input, failed inspection or review, other. A short list gets filled in; an open text box gets left blank.
- Charge the time to the work that caused itRework hours go on the original job or order number with a rework cost code, not on overhead or the next job. Create the cost code in your accounting system first, or the operating system may have nowhere to post it.
- Add a rework reason where changes are loggedIf you use Procore change events, add a custom reason for self-performed rework. The default reasons cover allowances, backcharges, client requests, design development and existing conditions, and none of those is your own redo. Other systems need the same: a reason that says this was ours.
- Review the tally weekly with whoever quotes the workFifteen minutes a week with the leads and the estimator or account owner. Pick the reason that cost the most hours and decide one change. In a certified steel shop this review is also how repeat nonconformances get caught.
Where do-it-yourself stops
These steps start a record and show you the biggest repeat causes. The tally is still paper that someone collects, adds up and retypes into the job cost, and the quality record and the cost record stay in two places. The lasting fix captures each redo where it happens, in a tool built around your own job costing and quality records, so the hours land on the right work with a reason the person quoting can see. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.
Questions people ask
What counts as rework?
The Navigant Construction Forum's 2012 paper uses this definition: work done more than once, or removal of work already installed, regardless of source, where no change order has been issued and the owner has identified no change of scope. The 2020 edition of AISC 207 separately defines rework as action that makes nonconforming work conform. Outside construction the same test works: it was done again, and the customer did not ask for the change.
How much does rework usually cost?
It depends on what was measured. In construction, Navigant's 2012 compilation of older studies gives a 4.03% median direct cost. A 2018 study of one Australian contractor found a mean of 0.39% of contract value. Owners in a 2022 Procore-sponsored FMI survey estimated 19%. These are not comparable figures.
Is rework under-recorded everywhere?
The construction evidence points that way. In a 2001 CII survey cited by Navigant, about a third of respondents believed they recorded only 50 to 75 percent of actual rework, and a 2025 study found one contractor's precompletion rework underreported by 300%.
Do AISC-certified shops have to record rework?
They must record nonconforming work: the pieces, the problem, the treatment, the authorization and reinspection, under the 2020 edition of AISC 207 section 1.15.2. The standard does not require recording the cost.
Should rework be charged back to the customer?
Only when the customer caused it, such as a revised drawing or changed instructions. Under Navigant's definition, work with a change order behind it is not rework at all. Recording every redo on the original work with a reason is how you tell the two apart.
Next step
How we fix this
This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.
Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.
