Problem guide
Estimates don't match what the work actually costs
Estimates and actuals drift apart because the estimate is built by cost code once, and actual cost arrives later through timesheets, receipts and bills that someone has to code the same way. ServiceTitan's help shows the catch: on a timesheet, the budget code fills in by itself only when the project budget has exactly one cost code; otherwise someone picks it by hand. Use the estimate's codes on every timesheet, time entry and purchase order.

How it actually happens
An estimate is a prediction written in cost codes. Whoever quotes the work breaks it into lines, puts hours and material on each, and adds markup. If the quote wins, those lines become the budget. From then on, the only way to know whether the prediction was right is for every hour and every dollar of cost to land on the same line it was estimated on. That holds for a construction bid, a fixed-fee engagement and a custom manufacturing order alike.
That is where it breaks. Follow a typical commercial electrical job, as an example. The estimator bid it in five phases. The project manager loads the sold estimate as the budget. The foreman's crew clocks in on the project, but the timesheet app offers forty cost codes, or none, so most hours land on rough-in or on a general code. Material is ordered on a purchase order coded to the project, and the bill arrives three weeks later and gets coded by the bookkeeper to whatever line looks closest. A change order for added fixtures is approved by the customer but never entered against the budget.
At closeout the job is over budget. The report says rough-in ran long and trim came in under, which is mostly a coding artifact. The real misses, the change that was never added and the gear that cost more than quoted, are buried. The estimator reads the summary and adds hours to rough-in on the next bid, which makes the next bid less competitive and fixes nothing.
A professional services firm runs the same loop with time entries. Staff record hours to the engagement but not the task, the client's added request never becomes a scope change, and the partner sees only that the fixed fee was blown. A manufacturer sees it when operators clock to the order but not the operation.
Software has a place for each piece, and a person has to fill it. In ServiceTitan the budget comes from the sold estimate and actuals start when bills and invoices arrive, but the cost code on a timesheet fills in by itself only on a single-code budget. A cost adjustment moves the budget only when someone builds it as a change-order estimate. In Procore, Send to Budget takes only the primary estimate, and a part with labor, material and tax becomes three lines. In Housecall Pro and Jobber, a raise applies only from the day it is entered.
FMI's 2023 study gives a sense of the stakes on the labor side in construction. Contractors there said they believe 11% to 15% of field labor cost is wasted or unproductive. Some of that is real lost time. Some of it, in any one company, is hours charged to the wrong line of a good estimate.
Fix the coding before the estimate
Before you change a single unit cost, rate or hour in your estimating data, clean one quarter of closed work: move miscoded cost, add missing changes, and wait for the bills. Only the variance that survives that cleanup is an estimating problem.
Signs you have this problem
- Every job or engagement closes over or under the quote and nobody can say which line caused it
- Hours show up on the wrong phase, task or operation, or under a catch-all code
- The estimator never sees what the last similar job actually cost
- A change order or scope change went through and the budget still shows the original numbers
- Material cost appears on the job weeks after the parts were used
What usually causes it
- Labor and material are coded when they are entered, by people who never saw the estimate, so cost lands on the wrong line or no lineThe field-to-office split
- The budget is built from the estimate once, and changes, re-estimates and decisions made during the work never flow back into itThe handoff gap
- Cost reaches the job only when a bill is entered, a receipt posts or payroll runs, so the comparison is made on partial actualsThe re-entry trap
- Uncoded and miscoded items pile into a catch-all bucket that nobody cleans upThe exception swamp
Find your cause
Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.
- Is more than a small share of labor on your work under a general or uncategorized code?If yes: the people entering time cannot see or pick the estimate's codes. Make the code required and limit the choices to the job's budget.
- Does the budget still show the original quote after changes are approved?If yes: nobody moves the budget. Enter every approved change against it the same day and compare to the current budget.
- Do jobs swing from under to over budget in the last weeks?If yes: you are comparing against partial actuals. Add committed cost and check when bills and payroll post.
- Does the estimator see closed-job results by cost code?If yes: if not, the next quote repeats the last miss. Send a one-page comparison at every closeout.
How it breaks in each industry
- Commercial electrical
- Bids are built by phase: underground, rough-in, trim, gear, low voltage. If the timesheet only knows the project, all labor lands on one line, and the variance by phase is lost. ServiceTitan's budget codes on timesheets fill in automatically only for single-code budgets.
- HVAC replacement and service
- The estimate lists equipment, material, labor and permit. Equipment cost may count on the purchase order, the receipt or the bill depending on the costing setting, so the same job shows three different margins depending on the day you look.
- Accounting, law and other professional services firms
- A fixed-fee engagement is priced by phase or task, but staff record time against the engagement as a whole or a general code. At wrap-up the firm knows it went over, not whether planning, fieldwork or review ran long, so the next year's fee is set from the same guess.
- Specialty manufacturing
- A custom order is quoted from a routing with setup and run time per operation. Operators clock to the order but not the operation, scrap and rework go to a general bucket, and the quote for the repeat order copies the original numbers because nobody can see which step cost more than planned.
Where it breaks between systems
- ServiceTitan Budget vs Actual
- Original Budget comes from the sold estimates; Total Budget adds change orders and cost adjustments; committed cost is purchase orders not yet received. Actuals start calculating only when an invoice is generated, bills are received or returns are issued. Technician actual is the hourly rate times paid hours, and anything without a label shows as Uncategorized.[1]
- ServiceTitan budget codes on timesheets
- A Private Preview feature that works only with flexible timekeeping. There is no global default cost code. The code fills in by itself only for Dispatched or Arrived entries when the project budget has exactly one cost code; in every other case someone selects it on the timesheet.[2]
- ServiceTitan cost adjustments
- Changes to the cost budget are made as change-order estimates, and the project type must have estimates enabled. Cost adjustments do not change the project total and do not show in the Change Order Summary of the continuation sheet. An internal re-estimate changes nothing until someone builds one.[3]
- ServiceTitan and QuickBooks
- ServiceTitan's QuickBooks FAQ says job costing is not sent to QuickBooks and should be referenced in ServiceTitan. Estimate-to-actual comparison has to happen on the field side, not in the books.[4]
- Procore Estimating to Budget
- Send to Budget copies line items only from the primary estimate, without any included estimates. A part with labor, materials and tax becomes three budget lines, budget codes depend on the project's work breakdown structure, and the company must be licensed for Project Financials.[6]
- Procore and Sage 300 CRE
- Budgets sent from Procore wait by default for an accounting approver, and exported budget entries are posted by hand in Sage Job Cost. Actual job cost moves the other way, from Sage into an ERP Direct Costs column in Procore. The budget can be newer in Procore while the actuals are newer in Sage.[7]
- Sage Estimating to Sage 300 CRE Job Cost
- Sage's integration guide (v22.1) says estimates go to Job Cost as budget entries in the New.jct file, and a standard cost code must already exist for every code sent. Database setting changes made after an estimate is created do not change its existing phases, items or addons.[8]
- Housecall Pro job costing
- Labor cost is the employee's fully loaded rate times time on the job, travel included, and a later rate change does not update labor already recorded. Material unit cost is entered by hand.[10]
- Jobber and QuickBooks
- Jobber's help says labor cost is timesheet hours times each employee's hourly cost, and a changed cost applies only to future hours. Costs first sync from QuickBooks, after which Jobber is the source of truth for them.[11]
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures |
|---|---|
| 11% to 15%[12] | Share of field labor cost contractors believe is wasted or unproductive, from all causes, in FMI's 2023 labor productivity study of 259 labor-intensive, self-performing US contractors, 42% of them MEP. A belief reported by respondents, not a measurement, and not specific to estimating. |
| 6% to 10%[12] | Share of labor spending the same respondents conservatively believe could be saved through better management practices, which FMI puts at $15 billion to $25 billion. An FMI economic estimate. |
Rules that apply
- AIA A201-2017, Section 7.3.4, cost records on directed changes[13]
- Under the unmodified form, when a Construction Change Directive is priced by the architect on reasonable expenditures, or on cost under 7.3.3.3, the contractor keeps and presents an itemized accounting with supporting data. Allowable cost is limited to listed items such as labor with payroll taxes and fringes, materials, equipment rental, bonds, insurance, permits and taxes, and supervision attributable to the change.
- AIA A201-2017, Section 9.2, schedule of values[13]
- On stipulated sum and guaranteed maximum price contracts, the schedule of values allocates the contract sum to portions of the work and becomes the basis for reviewing pay applications. If your estimate's cost codes do not map to it, billing progress and cost progress cannot be compared line by line.
Measure it in your own shop
From: The sold estimates or quotes for your last ten closed jobs of one type, with their cost codes, and the cost detail for the same jobs from your operating system or ledger, including timesheets and purchase orders.
- Lay each estimate next to its actuals by cost code, using the final budget including approved changes.
- For each job, add up the cost that landed on a general, uncategorized or wrong code.
- Mark each code's variance as over or under, and find the codes that miss in the same direction on most jobs.
- For three of the biggest misses, pull the timesheets or bills and write down why: wrong code, late cost, change not in the budget, or a real estimating miss.
Reading it: Cost on uncategorized or wrong codes is a coding problem, not an estimating one. Codes that miss the same way on most jobs are estimating problems: the unit costs or hours in the quote are wrong. Changes missing from the budget make the job look worse than it is. Fix them in that order, because a clean comparison is needed before the estimate can be corrected.
What does not fix it
- Padding the next estimate
- If the variance is miscoded labor or a change left out of the budget, padding hides it and loses bids. Find out which line actually missed first.
- Telling people to enter time daily
- Daily entry helps timing but not coding. In ServiceTitan, unless the budget has a single cost code, someone still picks the code on each timesheet, and a wrong pick is still wrong every day.
- A budget-versus-actual spreadsheet
- ServiceTitan's own template page points out that a spreadsheet does not update when a change order is approved; someone has to revise every affected line. It shows a $4,000 rough-in overrun as an example of a variance a spreadsheet can show but not explain.
What to try this week
- Estimate in the codes the people doing the work will useBuild the estimate on the same cost codes, phases or tasks that timesheets and purchase orders use. If the estimate says rough-in and trim, or planning and fieldwork, the timesheet has to offer exactly those.
- Make the code required, not optionalSet timesheet activities, time entries and purchase orders so they cannot be saved without a cost code. ServiceTitan lets a timesheet activity require a budget code; use that kind of setting wherever your system has one.
- Move the budget when the work changesEvery approved change order or scope change, and every internal re-estimate, gets entered against the budget the day it is approved. Compare actuals to the current budget, not the original quote.
- Count committed cost before you judgeLook at open purchase orders beside actuals before calling a job over or under. A job can look under budget only because the bills have not posted.
- Close the loop to the estimatorWhen a job closes, send whoever quoted it a one-page comparison by cost code with the three biggest variances and their reasons. The next quote should use it.
Where do-it-yourself stops
These steps make the estimate and the actuals speak the same codes and keep the budget current. Labor and material still get coded by hand as they come in, changes still move the budget only when someone enters them, and the estimator still waits for a report at closeout. The lasting fix is a tool built around your own estimate structure, so the people doing the work pick from the estimate's lines and the comparison updates as cost arrives. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.
Questions people ask
Why does our actual cost never match the estimate?
Usually because cost is coded differently from the estimate as it comes in, changes are not added to the budget, or bills and payroll have not posted yet. Check those three before deciding the estimate itself was wrong.
How much field labor is wasted on a typical construction job?
In FMI's 2023 labor productivity study, contractors said they believe 11% to 15% of field labor cost is wasted or unproductive, from all causes. It is a belief survey of 259 self-performing contractors, not a measurement of estimate misses.
Does ServiceTitan send job costing to QuickBooks?
No. ServiceTitan's QuickBooks FAQ says job costing is not sent to QuickBooks and should be referenced in ServiceTitan, so compare estimate to actual there.
When does actual cost show up in ServiceTitan's Budget vs Actual?
ServiceTitan's help says actuals start calculating when you generate an invoice, receive bills or issue returns. Purchase orders not yet received appear as committed costs, not actuals.
Do we need separate cost records for directed changes?
Under an unmodified AIA A201-2017, if a Construction Change Directive is priced on cost, you must keep and present an itemized accounting with supporting data, limited to the cost types section 7.3.4 lists. That needs labor and material on the change coded apart from the base work.
Next step
How we fix this
This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.
Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.
