Fox & SantiagoTechnology, applied.Call (877) 244-9687

Problem guide

Timecards need a supervisor to chase them

Timecards need chasing because payroll cannot move on hours nobody has approved, and in most time and payroll systems approval is the gate. Jobber sends timesheets to QuickBooks Online only after approval, QuickBooks Time sends only approved hours to QuickBooks Desktop, and ServiceTitan payroll leaves only when someone exports its Master Pay File. Give every card one approver and one deadline, and list the missing cards the day before payroll, not the morning of.

Two coffee cups, a phone and a notebook on a table by a morning window

How it actually happens

Every time system that feeds payroll has a gate, and the gate is approval. Hours that are not approved do not move. Jobber can hold timesheets back from QuickBooks Online until someone approves them. QuickBooks Time sends nothing to QuickBooks Desktop that is not approved. ServiceTitan does not send payroll to QuickBooks at all: someone approves the period, runs the Master Pay File and imports it. Vista can stop a card twice, once for the manager and once for the project manager on the job. In a restaurant or a clinic, the same gate is the manager's review of missed punches.

So the person running payroll cannot start until every card is in and approved, and nobody has a list of which ones are not. Here is a typical Monday at a 30-person service and construction company. Payroll is processed Tuesday morning. The office manager opens the approval screen and counts. Twenty-two cards are there. Of the other eight, three technicians forgot to submit Friday, two foremen have their crews' cards in the truck, one apprentice clocked in with the wrong job, and two people worked a public job where the certified payroll also needs a classification split.

She texts the three technicians. Two answer by lunch. She calls the foremen, who are on a roof and call back at four. One reads his crew's hours over the phone and she types them in. The project manager on the public job is in a meeting. At 6 p.m. she approves what she has so payroll can go, and the last card lands Tuesday at 7 a.m., after the period is locked. In ServiceTitan that late card does not even show on the payroll screen until someone clicks Update Now.

On the other side, it looks like this. A tech on Reddit's r/HVAC wrote in 2023 that his clock-in app sometimes came up short, the office usually fixed it, and the missing money sometimes took two to three weeks to arrive. Then five weeks in a row he worked 45 hours and was paid for fewer than 40. Whatever the cause at his company, a late fix turns into a trust problem with the team, and people stop submitting on time because they no longer believe the card matters.

Nothing in this story needs a lazy employee. It needs one person who owns every card, a deadline a day before payroll, and a list of who is missing at that deadline.

What the published numbers can and cannot tell you

Most timecard statistics on vendor sites trace back to no study at all. The one with a published method, EY's 2022 survey for payroll vendor Paycom, put the average payroll error at $291 to fix and found time and attendance errors the most common kind. It surveyed companies of 250 to 10,000 employees across industries, so it describes midsize employers in general, not any one trade. Your own late-card count will tell you more.

Signs you have this problem

  • Payroll morning starts with texts to employees asking for last week's hours
  • A supervisor fills in cards for the team from memory on Monday
  • Hours from a late card show up on the next check, not this one
  • The pay period got approved early, and later timesheets vanish from the payroll screen
  • On public jobs, the certified payroll waits on one missing card

What usually causes it

  • Approval is a required step and nobody owns getting every card to itApproval drag
  • Missing cards are invisible until the person running payroll goes lookingThe invisible queue
  • Hours are written on paper or in a notes app and retyped into the system that paysThe re-entry trap
  • The team lead, the manager and payroll each think another of them is collecting the cardsThe handoff gap

Find your cause

Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.

  1. Does any employee have two people who might approve his or her time?If yes: each one assumes the other did it. Name one approver per person.
  2. Does payroll find out who is missing only when it sits down to run?If yes: the missing list is the fix. Publish it at the deadline, a day earlier.
  3. Does someone retype hours from paper, texts or a notes app?If yes: the chase is really a re-entry job. Get the card into the system that pays, where it is written.
  4. Do late timesheets disappear after the period is approved?If yes: the period is being approved before it is complete. Move approval after the deadline.
  5. On public jobs, does certified payroll wait on cards?If yes: set the field deadline from the seven-day delivery rule backward, and track subs' payrolls separately.

How it breaks in each industry

HVAC, plumbing and electrical service
Technicians start from home and end at a customer, so there is no shop clock to pass. Hours sit on a phone app or a paper card in the truck until someone asks. The office often sees the work order times but not the paid hours, and has to ask which one is right.
Commercial electrical and mechanical on public work
Davis-Bacon work needs a weekly certified payroll for each covered week, and the prime is responsible for the subs' payrolls too. One missing card holds the whole report, and a journeyman who worked in two classifications needs his hours split by classification or he is owed the higher rate for all of them.
Restaurants and hospitality
Staff punch in at the point of sale, swap shifts by text and forget to punch out after a late close. The manager fixes missed punches before payroll from the schedule and memory, and tips have to be matched to the corrected hours before anything can be approved.
Healthcare practices and clinics
Hourly staff work across locations and cover each other's shifts, so the card sits with a manager who did not see the day. Missed punches pile up for the practice manager to approve, and a card that reaches payroll late pushes overtime into the wrong week.

Where it breaks between systems

ServiceTitan and QuickBooks
Invoices, payments, bills and returns export to QuickBooks directly. Payroll does not, and goes through the MasterPay report, with entries adjusted in the Excel file if payroll has to match job locations.[1]
ServiceTitan payroll approval
ServiceTitan's troubleshooting article explains that a manager approval locks the pay period: timesheets entered after the approval time do not appear in Payroll Approval or most payroll reports until someone clicks Update Now, and Undo Approval first if the tech is already approved.[2]
QuickBooks Time and QuickBooks Desktop
Only approved time exports. The Web Connector sends hours only when there are new approved timesheets, the export setting has to be on, and Intuit asks for the sync to run as admin in single-user mode. Edits made in Desktop after export do not come back to QuickBooks Time.[3]
Jobber timesheets
Only admins and users allowed to view, record and edit everyone's timesheets can approve. A tech with permission over his own time only cannot approve his own card.[4]
Jobber payroll
Jobber does not process payroll or pay employees. Confirm Payroll only marks time and expenses as paid inside Jobber, so the hours still have to reach the system that cuts checks.[5]
Housecall Pro and QuickBooks
Housecall Pro's QuickBooks Desktop sync article lists what moves: jobs, invoices, payments, customers and price book items. Timesheets are not on the list, so hours reach payroll by another path.[6]
Simpro and Xero Payroll
Simpro creates draft timesheets in Xero and cannot update them. Timesheets must be locked first, only the latest complete unsent period is offered, and once sent or marked exported a timesheet cannot be sent again, even if it is deleted in Xero.[7]
ServiceM8 and Xero, QuickBooks Online or MYOB
The paid Automated Timesheet Sync add-on sends Clock On and Off shift times, which are separate from job Check In and Out times. ServiceM8 will not switch the automatic export on until every staff export error is cleared.[8]
Viewpoint HR Management and Vista
Submitting locks the card for the employee. Manager approval and project manager job approval are both optional stops, and the manager keeps getting notices about unapproved cards unless a setting turns off approvals for past pay periods. Posting payroll in Vista closes the portal batch.[9]

By the numbers

FigureWhat it measures
$291 per error[11]Average cost to fix one payroll error, in a 2022 EY survey of 508 payroll staff at U.S. companies with 250 to 10,000 employees. The survey was commissioned and promoted by payroll vendor Paycom, and it is not a construction sample.
1,139 per 1,000 employees[11]Time, attendance and expense errors per 1,000 employees per year in the same Paycom-commissioned EY survey, the most common error type it measured. Not construction-specific.
$259 million[12]Back wages the Labor Department's Wage and Hour Division recovered in fiscal 2025 for about 177,000 workers, across all laws it enforces. Not a payroll-error rate, but it shows where unrecorded hours end up.
$450 to $550 billion (not time theft)[13]This figure circulates on vendor blogs as the yearly cost of time theft. It is Gallup's 2013 estimate of what active disengagement costs the U.S. economy, not a measurement of padded timecards.

Rules that apply

29 CFR 516.2(a)(7), daily and weekly hours[14]
Every covered employer keeps hours worked each workday and the total each workweek. The duty sits with the employer, so a card that never came in is the company's gap, not the tech's.
DOL Fact Sheet 21, any timekeeping method[15]
Employers may use a time clock, a timekeeper, or let workers write their own times, as long as the plan is complete and accurate. Paper is allowed. Incomplete is not.
29 CFR 516.5(a) and 516.6(a)(1), how long to keep them[17]
Payroll records are kept at least three years. The time cards with daily start and stop times behind them are kept at least two years, so a card rebuilt by a supervisor should not replace the original.
29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(A), weekly certified payroll[18]
On Davis-Bacon covered work, certified payrolls are submitted weekly for each week of covered work, and the prime contractor is responsible for every sub's payroll. A sub's late timecard becomes the prime's late report.
29 CFR 3.3(b) and 3.4(a), the signed weekly statement[20]
Each weekly payroll on covered work carries a signed statement of compliance from someone who supervises payment of wages, and it is delivered within seven days after the regular payment date. The requirement does not apply to contracts of $2,000 or less.

Measure it in your own shop

From: Timesheet submission and approval timestamps from your field system or time app (ServiceTitan, Jobber, QuickBooks Time, Housecall Pro, Vista HR Management), and your payroll calendar for the last six pay periods.

  1. For each period, list every hourly employee who worked and the time his card was submitted and approved.
  2. Mark each card submitted after your stated deadline and each card someone else entered for him.
  3. Count the cards approved after payroll processing started, and any hours paid a period late.
  4. Ask the approvers to estimate their time chasing each period, then check it against the late count.

Reading it: The share of late cards per period is your baseline. If the same five names make up most of it, the fix is with those five and their approvers. If it is spread across everyone, the deadline or the tool is the problem.

What does not fix it

A new time clock app
An app records the punch. It does not approve the card, and in Jobber, QuickBooks Time and ServiceTitan approval is still the gate payroll waits on. The chase moves from paper to notifications.
Docking or threatening late submitters
Federal rules put the recordkeeping duty on the employer, and hours worked are owed whether or not the card was on time. Withholding pay for hours worked creates a wage claim.
Letting the foreman fill in the crew's cards
It ends the chase by replacing the record. Under 29 CFR 516.6 the daily start and stop times behind payroll are a record you keep, and a reconstructed card from memory drops it.

What to try this week

  1. Name one approver per personWrite a list: every hourly employee, the one person who approves that employee's time, and a backup for weeks the approver is out. Two possible approvers means none.
  2. Set the deadline a day before payroll needs itIf payroll is processed Tuesday, cards are due Monday at noon and approved by Monday close. The day in between is for the exceptions, not the whole team.
  3. Publish the missing list at the deadlineAt noon on the due day, send the approvers a list of who has not submitted. One list, by name. Chasing becomes reading a list instead of remembering who is usually late.
  4. Stop approving the period earlyIn systems that lock a period on approval, an approval clicked before the last day's cards are in hides the late ones. Approve after the deadline, not as cards trickle in.
  5. Keep the original cardIf a supervisor rebuilds a card from memory, a schedule or a GPS log, keep the employee's original record with it. Federal rules require the time cards behind payroll to be kept for two years.

Where do-it-yourself stops

These steps cut the chase, but a person still compares who submitted against who worked, nags the rest, and moves approved hours from the time app into payroll by hand. The lasting fix is a tool built around your time system and payroll, so the missing cards show themselves by name at the deadline and approved hours reach payroll without a file in between. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.

How a Workflow Spec fixes it for good

Questions people ask

Why does QuickBooks not show hours from our field app?

Usually because they are not approved yet. QuickBooks Time sends only approved hours to QuickBooks Desktop, and Jobber's QuickBooks Online sync can be set to send timesheets only after approval.

Can ServiceTitan send payroll straight to QuickBooks?

No. ServiceTitan says payroll does not export directly. Someone approves the pay period, runs the Master Pay File, and imports it into the payroll provider.

Are paper timecards legal?

Yes. DOL Fact Sheet 21 says any timekeeping method is acceptable if it is complete and accurate, including workers writing their own times.

How long do we keep timecards?

At least two years for time cards with daily start and stop times (29 CFR 516.6), and three years for the payroll records built from them (29 CFR 516.5). On Davis-Bacon work, payroll records are kept three years after all work on the prime contract is done.

Is it true time theft costs U.S. business $450 billion a year?

That number is Gallup's 2013 estimate of the cost of active disengagement, not time theft. We found no primary study behind the time-theft percentages that circulate on vendor sites.

Next step

How we fix this

This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.

Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.