Problem guide
Crews arrive without the right parts or equipment
People arrive at the work short because what it needs is known by the customer, the last person who was there or the estimator, but the vehicle, cart or room is stocked from habit and restocked from invoices. In Aberdeen's 2013 survey of 156 field service organizations, 51% named missing or incorrect parts as a reason for repeat visits. Ask the right questions at intake, tie equipment history to the work order, and check tomorrow's work against what is actually where it will be done.

How it actually happens
Three people usually know what a job will need before the work starts: the customer who called, the person who was there last time, and sometimes an estimator who walked it. The person who loads the van or preps the room is usually none of them.
The call comes in. The customer says the rooftop unit on the north side is short cycling again. The call taker types "RTU short cycling" and books the first open slot. Last spring a tech replaced a contactor on that unit and wrote in his job note that the control board was failing and the hatch needs the long ladder. That note is attached to last spring's job. Today's tech never opens it. He loads what he always carries, drives out, climbs up, finds the board, and spends the next hour at the supply house.
The same break happens wherever work is done away from the main stock. A rental yard sends a machine without the attachment the customer's crew needs. A satellite clinic's supply closet is short the kit for a scheduled procedure. In each case the need was knowable the day before, and the place it was written down is not the place anyone looks while loading.
Aberdeen's 2013 research gives the shape of it across field service. More than half of visits need a part. When one does, even the best firms had it on the truck only 58% of the time, and everyone else 45%. Respondents ranked better diagnosis at the first call as the top fix, ahead of better access to parts. The firms that triaged every call fixed 86% on the first visit, against 62% for firms with no triage.
Then the count drifts. In ServiceTitan's original replenishment workflow, a part shows up as needing restock when it goes on an invoice. FieldEdge does not reduce a warehouse quantity until the invoice is finalized and posted to QuickBooks. ServiceM8 shows whatever quantity the accounting package last sent back. In each case the van is counted from billing, not from the shelf. A warranty swap, a part lent to another truck or a part someone forgot to add never reaches the count. QuickBooks Online cannot hold the count by van at all.
So the afternoon before, nobody can answer the one question that matters: does the truck going to that roof tomorrow have that board? The dispatcher has the schedule. The parts lead has a list of what was billed. The knowledge of what the unit needs is in a note from last spring.
In electrical construction the same gap shows up as material at the job instead of parts on a van. The ELECTRI researcher told Electrical Contractor that same-day and next-day orders arrived when, how and where wanted 63% of the time, against 99% for third-day delivery. His colleague added that a crew without the day's material moves to whatever task the material on hand allows, and productivity is lower on that backup plan.
Why the fix is upstream of the warehouse
Most businesses respond to a missed part by stocking more. Look at your own misses first. If the item was at the main location that morning, or someone on staff already knew the work needed it, more stock would not have helped. The fix sits at intake and in the afternoon check, where what is known about the work meets what is on the van or the shelf.
Signs you have this problem
- People leave the work partway through to go get a part or a supply
- The wrong lift, ladder, tool or attachment shows up because nobody knew the site conditions
- The person doing the work calls the office from site to ask what the work actually is
- The part was sitting at the main location while someone drove to a supplier
- The software says a van or a satellite stockroom holds an item nobody can find
What usually causes it
- What the customer said or the last person saw on site is not passed to whoever loads the van or preps the workThe handoff gap
- Parts and supply needs are written in notes that someone has to read and retype into a pick listThe re-entry trap
- Nobody sees which of tomorrow's jobs are still short an item until the work has startedThe invisible queue
- Stock away from the main location is counted in a system that only learns about usage when an invoice postsThe field-to-office split
Find your cause
Ask these in order. The first yes is usually where yours starts.
- Was the missing item at your main location that morning?If yes: this is a loading and information problem, not a stocking one. Start with the four o'clock load check.
- Had a previous visit already recorded the model, the part or the access problem?If yes: the knowledge stopped in a note. Move it to the site's equipment record so the next booking sees it.
- Was the work dispatched without asking what the equipment is and what it is doing?If yes: intake is the gap. Script the booking questions.
- Does restocking come only from items that went on invoices?If yes: items used without an invoice line, warranty swaps and loans between locations never get replaced. Count one location by hand.
- Does the stock count in software disagree with the shelf when someone checks?If yes: transfers, returns or usage are being recorded somewhere else, or not at all. Fix where they are entered before trusting the count.
How it breaks in each industry
- HVAC and plumbing service
- The part is usually a specific board, motor, valve or capacitor for one make and model. The caller rarely knows the model, the last tech wrote it in a note, and the van was restocked only for what went on invoices last week. Refrigerant adds a record: on larger commercial systems, every pound added has to be written up for the owner.
- Electrical construction
- The miss is material at the job, not a part on a van. ELECTRI's 2008 study found electricians could spend an average of 40% of their time on handling material and set the ideal on-site stock at three days. Same-day and next-day orders arrived when, how and where wanted 63% of the time in the researcher's account.
- Roofing
- The miss is equipment and access as often as material: the lift, the hatch, the length of ladder, the tear-off disposal. Consumables are counted on paper and typed in later, so the office learns what the crew used after the job is billed.
- Equipment rental
- The machine goes out on the delivery truck, and the attachment, the bucket size or the trailer it needs is decided by whoever wrote the order. When the order only says the model, the driver arrives with the machine and the customer's crew waits for a second trip.
- Healthcare practices and clinics
- Supplies for a procedure are stocked in the room or a satellite clinic's supply closet, and restocked from what was charged. The schedule knows tomorrow's procedures. Nobody checks them against the closet, so the miss is found with the patient in the room.
Where it breaks between systems
- ServiceTitan, original truck replenishment
- The original workflow does not track on-hand quantity on the truck. It tracks what needs restocking as techs add materials to invoices, and it cannot run alongside QuickBooks inventory. ServiceTitan notes the feature has been updated for most users; shops still on it see restock demand, not what is on the van.[9]
- ServiceTitan Inventory module
- Trucks and warehouses become locations with quantity on hand, available, on hold and on order. Account configuration is required to use it, so a shop has to set it up before a dispatcher can see what a given van holds.[10]
- ServiceTitan and QuickBooks Online
- ServiceTitan recommends most shops create items in QuickBooks Online as non-inventory, matches items by the pricebook Code against the QuickBooks item Name, and says returns and transfers do not export and must be created by hand. A van-to-van transfer lives only in ServiceTitan.[11]
- QuickBooks Online on its own
- An Intuit staff reply in March 2026 says location tracking in QuickBooks Online is for tagging and reporting and does not track inventory quantities by location. A shop counting vans in QuickBooks Online alone cannot see what is on each truck.[12]
- FieldEdge and QuickBooks Enterprise
- Warehouses in FieldEdge need QuickBooks Enterprise with Advanced Inventory and warehouses created in QuickBooks, and quantities do not change until the invoice is finalized and posted to QuickBooks. A part used this morning still shows on the van until billing is done.[14]
- ServiceM8 and Xero, MYOB or QuickBooks Online
- Stock for integrated items is managed in the accounting package and ServiceM8 shows the imported quantity. Changing it in ServiceM8 makes no adjustment in the books, and a later import can replace the manual change. The documented field is one quantity per material, not one per vehicle.[15]
- Housecall Pro and QuickBooks Online
- Housecall Pro's own help points pros to QuickBooks Online Plus for inventory, with materials accounted for when the invoice syncs, and lists an add-on (Ply) for more. There is no native count by truck in that article.[16]
- BuildOps
- BuildOps says it tracks stock across warehouses, trucks and job sites, and that stock counts reflect what has been entered, with physical counts needing a manual reconciliation step.[17]
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures |
|---|---|
| 75%[1] | Average first-time fix rate across 156 field service organizations surveyed by Aberdeen Group in January 2013. Best-in-Class firms reached 89%, all others 71%. Field service broadly, not a trades-only sample. |
| 51%[1] | Share of those 156 respondents who named missing or incorrect parts as a reason for a second or third visit (Aberdeen 2013). It is a share of respondents, not a share of repeat visits. |
| 58% vs 45%[1] | When a visit needs a service part, how often it is already in the technician's truck: Best-in-Class against all others. Aberdeen's research put the share of visits that need a part at more than half. |
| 1.6[1] | Additional dispatches, on average, for each call not fixed on the first visit (Aberdeen 2013). |
| $200 to $300[1] | Aberdeen's general operating cost of a single truck roll, in 2013 dollars, which it says varies by industry and work type. |
| 86% vs 62%[1] | First-time fix where every call is routed through triage, against firms with no triage at all (Aberdeen 2013). |
| 61%[2] | Respondents whose customers most often complain that the technician did not resolve the issue, parts or expertise included (Aberdeen, January 2016 survey, n=182). |
| 19%[3] | HVAC and plumbing service companies in the MSCA 2022 Benchmark Survey that do not track truck inventory at all; 68% still tracked tools manually or not at all. Best-in-Class firms track truck inventory in software. Source is MCAA's published summary, reprinted by MAPIC in 2023. |
| 40%[4] | Average share of electricians' time that could go to non-value-added material handling (waiting, unloading, ordering, sorting, returns), per the authors of ELECTRI International's 2008 jobsite inventory study. |
| 63%, 95%, 99%[5] | How often material arrived when, how and where it was wanted for same-day or next-day, second-day and third-day delivery, as the ELECTRI researcher described the study to Electrical Contractor magazine in 2007. |
| $31.14[6] | Mean hourly wage of HVAC mechanics and installers, May 2025 (BLS OEWS, 409,670 employed). Wage only; your loaded cost per hour is higher. |
| $34.37[7] | Mean hourly wage of electricians, May 2025 (BLS OEWS, 757,220 employed). |
| $27.95[8] | Mean hourly wage of roofers, May 2025 (BLS OEWS, 135,490 employed). |
Rules that apply
- 40 CFR 82.157(l), refrigerant service records[22]
- For each service on an appliance with a full charge of 50 lb or more of an ozone-depleting refrigerant, the servicer gives the owner a record that includes the amount and type of refrigerant added, kept at least three years. Refrigerant that leaves the truck has to be tied to an appliance and a visit, not just restocked.
- 40 CFR 84.106, HFC leak repair[23]
- Since January 1, 2026, the same kind of record applies to appliances holding 15 lb or more of an HFC refrigerant, with three-year retention. Home and light-commercial AC and heat pump systems are excluded from it.
Measure it in your own shop
From: Your work order history and appointments (ServiceTitan, FieldEdge, Housecall Pro, Jobber, simPRO or your own system), supplier receipts and will-call orders with their timestamps, and any stock transfer records.
- Pull every job from the last 30 working days that needed a second visit, or had a supplier purchase timed while the work was in progress.
- For each one, mark what was missing, whether it was at the main location that morning, and whether anyone knew before dispatch that it would be needed.
- Add up the hours from leaving the site to getting back, or to the second visit, and price them at your own loaded labor rate.
- Divide the parts-caused trips by all jobs dispatched in the same period.
Reading it: The rate is your own miss rate. The share where the item was already at the main location is the part a load check fixes. The share where someone knew in advance is the part better handoffs fix. What remains is a true stocking question.
What does not fix it
- Loading every van or closet with everything
- It ties up money in stock that sits for months and still misses the one board for the one unit. A tech on r/HVAC joked that he stocks twenty of something that never moves and then needs five of what he skipped.
- Turning on an inventory module and walking away
- A count away from the main location is only as good as the transfers and usage people record. BuildOps says it plainly: counts reflect what has been entered. Without a rule for who records a loan between locations, the screen drifts from the shelf.
- A supplier lookup in the quoting tool
- Jobber's February 2026 update shows Home Depot stock at stores within 50 miles while you build a quote. That tells you the store has it. It does not tell you the van does, and the trip to the store is the trip you were trying to avoid.
- Making each person responsible for their own van or room
- It works until the person who knows that stock is out, and it leaves the office with no view of what is where when it assigns tomorrow's work.
What to try this week
- Script three questions at intakeMake whoever takes the request ask the same three things every time: the make and model on the tag, how the equipment is reached, and what it is doing. Aberdeen's respondents ranked better diagnosis at the first call as the top way to raise first-time fix.
- Put the equipment record on the work orderWhen someone finds a model number, a control board or a roof hatch that needs a longer ladder, it goes on the site's equipment record, not in a note on one visit. The next booking at that address should show it.
- Run a four o'clock load checkEach afternoon one named person compares tomorrow's work against the main stock and what is on each van, cart or satellite shelf. Any job with a likely part that is not where the work will happen gets a transfer, a will-call order or a different assignment before morning.
- Code every parts runGive the parts run its own reason code or work type, with a field for what was missing and whether it was at the main location. Without a code the trip disappears into drive time.
- Count one location by hand this monthPick one van or one satellite stockroom, count it, and compare it to what your software says. The gap tells you whether that count can be trusted for the afternoon check.
Put a number on it
- Second trip calculator: Calculate what return trips cost your company each year when jobs cannot be finished on the first visit.
Where do-it-yourself stops
These steps catch more of the misses and show where they start. They still depend on one person reading notes, checking stock and remembering what the last visit found. The lasting fix is a tool built around your booking screen, your equipment history and your inventory system, so the likely parts are known at intake and checked against the assigned van or location before anyone leaves. That is what a Workflow Spec designs.
Questions people ask
How often do crews arrive without the right part?
No trade association publishes a rate for the trades. The closest figure is Aberdeen's 2013 field service research: when a visit needed a part, Best-in-Class firms had it on the truck 58% of the time and everyone else 45%. Count your own using the steps above.
What does a wasted trip cost?
Aberdeen put a single truck roll at $200 to $300 in 2013 dollars, and found 1.6 extra dispatches on average for each call not fixed the first time. Price your own with your loaded labor rate, vehicle cost and the job that waited.
Can QuickBooks Online track what is on each van?
Not by location. An Intuit staff reply in March 2026 says QuickBooks Online locations are for tagging and reporting and do not track quantities by location. QuickBooks Desktop Enterprise with Advanced Inventory can set up trucks as inventory sites.
Does ServiceTitan show what is on the truck?
It depends on the setup. The original truck replenishment workflow tracks what needs restocking, not what is on hand. The Inventory module shows quantity on hand per truck and warehouse once the account is configured for it.
Do refrigerant records affect truck stock?
On larger commercial systems, yes. Under 40 CFR 82.157(l), and 84.106 for HFC systems of 15 lb or more since January 2026, the owner gets a record of the refrigerant added on each service. Each pound on the truck has to be traceable to a job.
Next step
How we fix this
This guide is how to find it and work around it. If it keeps coming back, it is rarely the only thing costing you. We come on site, find the issues costing you the most, and fix them, starting with the most pressing.
Fox & Santiago, Genesee, Idaho. We work nationwide, for clients across the United States, from our headquarters in Genesee, Idaho.
